19 Organic & All Natural Eyeliners Rated By Beauty Experts

19 Organic & All Natural Eyeliners Rated By Beauty Experts

LAST UPDATED: 06/29/2019

tamryn-burgess_3

WRITTEN BY: TAMRYN BURGESS
Licensed Aesthetician 

This article may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy for more details. To learn more about how we selected the products featured on this list, check out our product review & research standards.

Eyeliners have been used for centuries to create dramatic shapes and designs around the eye. From Queen Cleopatra to modern icons like Sophia Loren and Brigitte Bardot, their signature smokey and cat-eyes could never be complete, or dare we say possible, without a high-quality eyeliner.

Organic and all-natural eyeliners are a must add to your makeup routine. Why? Because true natural eyeliners are made with real fruits, herbs, and nourishing plant oils. They get their smooth creamy textures and vibrant colors from natural sources like beeswax and carnauba wax (hypoallergenic and antibacterial), jojoba oil (nourishing and safe for sensitive skin), as well as earth minerals and pigments of berries and teas for pigment. The best natural eyeliners use preservatives like vitamin E, citric acid, zinc, and fermented radish root. All of these yummy ingredients work together to both nourish your delicate eye skin and deliver a stunning look.

Natural eyeliners can be found in liquid, gel, and pencil form and they work pretty similarly to their conventional counterparts. Although, finding an organic eyeliner that we could faithfully call “waterproof” was a challenge, there were definitely a few products that were “water resistant” and held up well during outdoor activities and sweaty exercise.

Unfortunately, finding an effective natural eyeliner made from delicious natural ingredients above can be a challenge. Lots of beauty companies are jumping on the “organic” bandwagon and greenwashing their products with unregulated and deceiving terms like “chemical-free,” “all natural,” and “organic” while simultaneously using ingredients that are none of the above.

To help you find the best natural eyeliners, our team of beauty experts researched and tested over 30 different to bring you this top list of the best of the best. These eyeliners are 1) actually made with natural + organic ingredients 2) do not contain ingredients such as coal tars, formaldehyde, parabens, artificial dyes and lake dyes, talc, phthalates and artificial fragrances, petrochemicals, or any other ingredients on our prohibited list and 3) were crafted by expert cosmetic formulators 4) loved by our research team!

In short–these are the natural eyeliners you’ve been searching for.  Enjoy!

FILTER BY TYPE

Vapour Organic Beauty – Mesmerize Organic Eyeliner ($20)

A high performing organic eyeliner without the chemical adhesives. This gorgeous and lustrous eyeliner comes in three shades - black velvet, taupey brown and decadent plum. Goes on gently without skipping or pulling the eyelid and offers a precise line for a defined eye, or use the blending tool to easily create a seductive smokey eye. Made with 70% certified organic ingredients like coconut oil (anti-aging), sunflower seed oil, (combats acne and inflammation) and chamomile (eliminate acne scars).

100% Pure – Long Lasting Organic Eyeliners ($30)

It can be surprisingly difficult to find a solid performing eyeliner that isn't filled with toxins and undesirable ingredients; however, these fruit pigmented eyeliners are close to perfect. They are made with certified organic ingredients like black tea and aloe and all-natural ingredients like oregano leaf, thyme, rosemary, and honeysuckle flower. Perfect for sensitive skin and eyes. Goes on like liquid silk, doesn't smudge, and smells like fruit!

The Ox Box: Organic Beauty Subscription Box

Can't decide which yummy organic skin care products to try first? Then let us choose the best skin care products for your skin type with our quarterly organic beauty box! Choose from 3 different boxes (based on your skin type) and get a full skin care routine for 40-50% off retail. Limited quantities each season. Get your favorites while they last!

Ecco Bella Vegan Organic Beauty – Natural Soft Pencil Eyeliners

An environmentally friendly eyeliner that won’t irritate your eyes or skin. This natural eyeliner comes in four shades and are made from vegetable waxes. Rich in palm and palm kernel glycerides to help draw a smooth, flawless line to define eyes softly without pulling or tugging. It is a soft pencil, but doesn’t crumble or fail to sharpen. Creates a beautiful smudged line, but can make a sharp defined line when freshly sharpened or even a little cool after sticking it in the freezer for a few minutes.

Hush + Dotti – Organic Liquid Eyeliner ($26)

Formulated with vitamin E and aloe to glide across the lashes smoothly, this organic eyeliner is easy-to-use and stays on from day to night. The flexible brush-like pen applicator makes creating the thinnest or thickest lines a breeze. This eyeliner is gentle, easy to remove and 100% waterproof. Shake it well before using and apply to achieve desired effect. Using in the water line of the eye is not recommended. Blended with rosemary leaf and chamomile extract to protect the skin.

Ilia – Pure Eyeliner ($24)

An all natural eyeliner without the mess of sharpening before each use as the twist up application comes with a built in sharpener. This one comes in four different rich, creamy and buildable shades for gorgeous defined eyes. Goes on smooth and packed with the healing oils of vitamin E and sesame to work alongside soothing butters of shea and coconut to moisturize and protect the delicate area of the eye. Contains 42% organic ingredients and may contain mica, iron oxides and titanium dioxide.

Ere Perez – All Natural Jojoba Eyeliners ($21)

An ideal natural eyeliner for those with really sensitive skin. This Australian owned company keeps it simple and carefully selects their ingredients to create gentle, highly effective natural makeup. There are eight shades available ranging from clay to a shimmery stone color. Formulated with soothing oils including jojoba and coconut to help protect eyelids and stimulate lash growth. The light-weight texture makes it easy to apply. Contains mica for natural pigmentation and may contain iron oxides.

Au Naturale – Essential Organic Eyeliner Pencil ($22)

An ideal organic eyeliner pencil for those with very sensitive skin. There are eight colors available ranging from subtle ocean blue to an essential matte black. Formulated with a ton of organic ingredients including castor seed oil (keeps moisture and pigment), jojoba seed oil (anti-inflammatory) and candelilla wax (vegan alternative to beeswax). These eyeliners are highly pigmented and great for all skin types, even those with oily skin. May contain mica, iron oxides and titanium dioxide.

Juice Beauty – Phyto-Pigments All Natural Liquid Eyeliner ($24)

An intense black liquid eyeliner made with certified organic ingredients like cranberry seed oil (highly moisturizing), jojoba oil (high in essential fatty acids) and aloe juice (anti-inflammatory). Rich in black color from plant-derived pigments of daisy, cranberry, turmeric, basil and henna. The applicator isn’t too thick, allowing you the flexibility to design your favorite line, thick or thin. Long wear without the coal, tar and synthetic dyes. May contain iron oxides (natural mineral sources).

100% Pure – Long Last Natural Eyeliner Pencils ($26)

A natural eyeliner pencil perfect for those with sensitive eyes. This creamy long-lasting formula glides on your eyelids like silk to define your eyes while nourishing your skin. All four shades are blended with natural ingredients like sunflower seed oil (combats acne and inflammation), vitamin E (restores and protects from free radical damage) and marula oil (high in antioxidants and treats dry skin). No cheap fillers, doesn’t smear and lasts all day. This one requires an eye pencil sharpener.

Kjaer Weis – Certified Organic Eye Pencil ($30)

A certified organic eye pencil by the European Organic Certifiers Council. Comes in four shades and is highly pigmented by naturally occurring mineral pigments. The purple is a gorgeous shade for those who like a bright and bold look. In keeping with the Kjaer Weis mission to combine luxury, performance, and safe ingredients, the pencils are formulated with the best natural and organic raw materials, for a soft, buttery-smooth feel, and are refillable just like the rest of the collection.

Hynt Beauty – High Definition Natural Eyeliner ($20)

A high definition vegan eyeliner that has a luxurious feel. The velvety formulation feels gentle on delicate skin, making it an ideal eyeliner for sensitive eyes. Blended with coconut oil and vegetable oils giving it a creamy texture that’s easy to apply. The pencil comes with a smudge tip to soften the line or create a more dramatic smokey eye look. Available in black and brown, it’s the perfect natural eyeliner staple for your makeup bag. PETA approved and free from all the nasty ingredients.

Jane Iredale – Natural Eye Pencil

An all natural eyeliner that enhances the eyes with a subtle, soft or dramatic line as it hydrates and protects the delicate skin of your eyelid. Formulated with moisturizing shea butter and vitamin E to protect the skin from creasing. The pencil is soft and glides on easily without tugging, just be gentle when sharpening. Contains natural mineral pigments to deliver long-lasting color. Seven shades available including a white pencil to add to the corner of the eye to make the eyes appear wider.

Lily Lolo – Natural Eyeliner ($16)

An affordable yet luxurious natural eyeliner without the toxic ingredients. This London based company creates 100% all natural makeup with sensitives in mind and this eyeliner stays true to that. Enriched with organic moisturizing ingredients like organic jojoba oil (moisturize the skin), shea butter (protect the skin) and vitamin E (anti-aging) for smooth application to the eyelids. Free from harsh chemicals, dyes and fillers and contains antibacterial properties to help improve the skin.

Inika – Certified Organic Eye Liner Pencil

This eco-conscious Austrlian owned company company makes organic eye pencils in addition to their organic liquid eyeliner. This certified organic eye pencil offers 8 gorgeous shades that are crafted from natural plant-based ingredients and pure mineral pigments. Packed with organic vegetable oils and certified organic coconut oil for added softness and nourishment, this one is suitable for sensitive eyes and glides on easily without smudging. Does not contain carmine or any other animal products.

Alima Pure – Natural Definition Eye Pencil

This mess-free natural eyeliner made in the Czech Republic comes in three different shades - black, brown and a shimmery taupe. Formulated with plant-based oils like jojoba oil (anti-inflammatory) and meadowfoam seed oil (locks in moisture) to ensure a smooth and soft application. These pencils are highly pigmented with natural mineral sources and have a strong staying power, especially when topped with a translucent powder. Contains chamomile flower extract to soothe and protect the eyes.

Burt’s Bees – Nourishing All Natural Eyeliner Pencil

Burt’s Bees hit a homerun with this eyeliner - affordable, natural, vegan and made without all the nasty ingredients in most conventional brands. Crafted with jojoba, mango and responsibly sourced meadowfoam seed oils to help nourish the skin. Available in three distinct shades and the pencil itself is made of responsibly sourced cedar wood. This one is smudge-proof and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Use makeup remover to remove this eyeliner as it’s long lasting and stays put.

Hush + Dotti – Organic Gel Liner ($26)

Eye pencils don’t tickle your fancy? You don’t have to be a pro with this gel liner. You just have to have a brush. This organic gel based eyeliner formula glides across lashes for a natural, smooth line. It’s 100% waterproof and great for those with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Crafted with castor oil (reduces acne), coconut oil (anti-aging) and grape oil (vitamin E) to nourish and protect the skin. A little of this gel liner goes a long way and it’s perfect for everyday use.

Vert Beauty – Organic Eyeliner Pencil ($17)

Infused with an anti-aging blend of mango and meadowfoam seed oils, the vegan formula glides on like a dream (no tugging or skipping) while keeping the delicate skin around the eyes soft and hydrated. This organic eyeliner pencil is available in five colors and can be used to achieve diverse looks, from subtle to dramatic for any occasion. The primary ingredient in this eyeliner is jojoba oil (anti-inflammatory and reduces redness) and the natural mineral sources used provide a hint of shimmer.

Inika – Certified Organic Liquid Eyeliner

Combining all-natural aloe vera, black tea leaf extract and pure mineral pigments, this certified organic liquid eyeliner provides rich color and longevity. The star ingredient, aloe, is rich in antioxidants and minerals which can help speed healing. Crafted with 70% organic ingredients and free from quick drying alcohols, this one is great for those with sensitive eyes. The precision tip allows for a meticulous and easy application. Great for all skin types.

PRODUCT BADGES LEGEND
100% NATURAL

100% NATURAL

The product contains only natural ingredients (non-synthetic or lab created). It does not contain anything artificial or synthetic.

100% ORGANIC

100% ORGANIC

The product has been formulated with 100% organically sourced and/or certified organic ingredients.

GMO FREE

GMO FREE

This product does not contain ingredients which have been genetically modified.

GLUTEN FREE

GLUTEN FREE

All of the ingredients contained in the product are free from gluten, wheat, and ingredients which are commonly contaminated with gluten.

VEGAN

VEGAN

The product is made without animal products or byproducts such as beeswax, honey, milk, eggs, etc.

CERTIFIED ORGANIC

CERTIFIED ORGANIC

The product has received an official organic certification from a third party organization such as the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA Certified Organic), ECOCERT, Australian Certified Organic, and others.

Leave a Reply