20 Organic & All Natural Eyeliners Rated By Beauty Experts

20 Organic & All Natural Eyeliners Rated By Beauty Experts

PUBLISHED: 06/29/2019 | LAST UPDATED: 01/17/2020

tamryn-burgess_3

WRITTEN BY: TAMRYN BURGESS
Licensed Aesthetician 

This article may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy for more details. To learn more about how we selected the products featured on this list, check out our product review & research standards.

Eyeliners have been used for centuries to create dramatic shapes and designs around the eye. From Queen Cleopatra to modern icons like Sophia Loren and Brigitte Bardot, their signature smokey and cat-eyes could never be complete, or dare we say possible, without a high-quality eyeliner.

Organic and all-natural eyeliners are a must add to your makeup routine. Why? Because true natural eyeliners are made with real fruits, herbs, and nourishing plant oils. They get their smooth creamy textures and vibrant colors from natural sources like beeswax and carnauba wax (hypoallergenic and antibacterial), jojoba oil (nourishing and safe for sensitive skin), as well as earth minerals and pigments of berries and teas for pigment. The best natural eyeliners use preservatives like vitamin E, citric acid, zinc, and fermented radish root. All of these yummy ingredients work together to both nourish your delicate eye skin and deliver a stunning look.

Natural eyeliners can be found in liquid, gel, and pencil form and they work pretty similarly to their conventional counterparts. Although, finding an organic eyeliner that we could faithfully call “waterproof” was a challenge, there were definitely a few products that were “water resistant” and held up well during outdoor activities and sweaty exercise.

Unfortunately, finding an effective natural eyeliner made from delicious natural ingredients above can be a challenge. Lots of beauty companies are jumping on the “organic” bandwagon and greenwashing their products with unregulated and deceiving terms like “chemical-free,” “all natural,” and “organic” while simultaneously using ingredients that are none of the above.

To help you find the best natural eyeliners, our team of beauty experts researched and tested over 30 different to bring you this top list of the best of the best. These eyeliners are 1) actually made with natural + organic ingredients 2) do not contain ingredients such as coal tars, formaldehyde, parabens, artificial dyes and lake dyes, talc, phthalates and artificial fragrances, petrochemicals, or any other ingredients on our prohibited list and 3) were crafted by expert cosmetic formulators 4) loved by our research team!

In short–these are the natural eyeliners you’ve been searching for.  Enjoy!

FILTER BY TYPE

TAKE THE QUIZ & FIND THE PERFECT NATURAL EYELINER

Make sure that the next natural eyeliner that you try is the right one for you! Get matched to your perfect organic and all natural eyeliners in seconds with our Organic & Natural Eyeliners Quiz. Click now to get started.

The Quick Flick – All Natural Quick Winged Eyeliner & Stamp ($29.99)

Honestly, this natural eyeliner is pure genius! On one end, you have a normal felt-tipped point to create an impeccably straight line (even if you are a novice). On the other end, is a stamp to create the perfect winged eyeliner look every. single. time. The applicator comes in a variety of sizes depending on how big or small you like your winged look. Additionally, the actual formula glides on easily, stays put, and creates a brilliantly dark black line. If you can't tell, we're obsessed.

*100% Pure – Long Lasting Liquid Organic Eyeliners ($30)

It can be surprisingly difficult to find a solid performing eyeliner that isn't filled with toxins and undesirable ingredients; however, these fruit pigmented eyeliners are close to perfect. They are made with certified organic ingredients like black tea and aloe and all-natural ingredients like oregano leaf, thyme, rosemary, and honeysuckle flower. Perfect for sensitive skin and eyes. Goes on like liquid silk, doesn't smudge, and smells like fruit!

*Hush + Dotti – Organic Liquid Eyeliner ($26)

Formulated with vitamin E and aloe to glide across the lashes smoothly, this organic eyeliner is easy-to-use and stays on from day to night. The flexible brush-like pen applicator makes creating the thinnest or thickest lines a breeze. This eyeliner is gentle, easy to remove and 100% waterproof. Shake it well before using and apply to achieve desired effect. Using in the water line of the eye is not recommended. Blended with rosemary leaf and chamomile extract to protect the skin.

*Zuzu Luxe – Liquid Eyeliner ($15.60)

One of the best clean eyeliners we've tested! This eyeliner is crafted to last all day, but may be a little more slippery for those with oilier lids. The color is super dark and bold, the applicator makes it easy to glide on a straight line, and it stays put once dry. It's made with a host of natural ingredients including aloe, jojoba, bentonite clay, eyebright, and natural minerals. Best of all--this eyeliner comes in 8 stunning shades (some with heavy shimmer) including blues, pinks, oranges, and greens!

*Juice Beauty – Phyto-Pigments All Natural Liquid Eyeliner ($24)

An intense black liquid eyeliner made with certified organic ingredients like cranberry seed oil (highly moisturizing), jojoba oil (high in essential fatty acids) and aloe juice (anti-inflammatory). Rich in black color from plant-derived pigments of daisy, cranberry, turmeric, basil and henna. The applicator isn’t too thick, allowing you the flexibility to design your favorite line, thick or thin. Long wear without the coal, tar and synthetic dyes. May contain iron oxides (natural mineral sources).

GET MATCHED! TAKE THE NATURAL EYELINERS QUIZ

Need help finding the perfect organic and natural eyeliner for you? Then, take our free Organic & Natural Eyeliner Quiz & get matched with the best natural eyeliner! We've created a custom quiz to help you quickly find the top 5 eyeliners. Takes just a few seconds to complete---click to get started!

*Inika – Certified Organic Liquid Eyeliner

Combining all-natural aloe vera, black tea leaf extract and pure mineral pigments, this certified organic liquid eyeliner provides rich color and longevity. The star ingredient, aloe, is rich in antioxidants and minerals which can help speed healing. Crafted with 70% organic ingredients and free from quick drying alcohols, this one is great for those with sensitive eyes. The precision tip allows for a meticulous and easy application. Great for all skin types.

PRODUCT BADGES LEGEND
100% NATURAL

100% NATURAL

The product contains only natural ingredients (non-synthetic or lab created). It does not contain anything artificial or synthetic.

100% ORGANIC

100% ORGANIC

The product has been formulated with 100% organically sourced and/or certified organic ingredients.

GMO FREE

GMO FREE

This product does not contain ingredients which have been genetically modified.

GLUTEN FREE

GLUTEN FREE

All of the ingredients contained in the product are free from gluten, wheat, and ingredients which are commonly contaminated with gluten.

VEGAN

VEGAN

The product is made without animal products or byproducts such as beeswax, honey, milk, eggs, etc.

CERTIFIED ORGANIC

CERTIFIED ORGANIC

The product has received an official organic certification from a third party organization such as the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA Certified Organic), ECOCERT, Australian Certified Organic, and others.

Leave a Reply